Metal Roof vs Shingles: Which Fits Your Roofing Needs?

A new roof can set you back anywhere between $4,900 to $14,100 today, depending on a variety of factors. One of those factors is, of course, the type of roofing material you choose. 

There’s a myriad of roofing materials from which you can choose today. Different homeowners, architects, and builders have different views of what roofing material is best. In reality, all roofing materials have their pros and cons.

The choice as to which material is ideal is, thus, a matter of individual tastes. The metal roof vs shingles debate is a common one, given that these materials are two of the most popular roofing materials in the United States. 

In today’s comprehensive post, we settle the metal vs shingle roofing debate once and for all. We’ll take a look at how the two compare when it comes to several essential factors, so it’s easier for you to make a decision on which material will suit your needs best.

Read on to learn more.


Metal roofs come in a large variety of styles. You can choose between different metals, including aluminum, steel, stainless steel, zinc, titanium, and copper. 

Some metals, like steel, require a coating to prevent rusting. Others, like aluminum, don’t. The choice is entirely up to the homeowner.

Asphalt shingles don’t come in as many varieties. Homeowners have a choice between fiberglass shingles and organic shingles.

The difference between the two varieties is that fiberglass shingles have a fiberglass 3-core that’s layered with asphalt. Organic shingles, on the other hand, have a felt layer covered with asphalt.


Asphalt shingles are by far the most popular building materials in America, partly because of their irresistible layered appearance. These shingles vary in color to perfectly complement the brick or paint of your home. Three-tab shingles usually give your home a flat appearance, while architectural shingles have an elegant three-dimensional appearance.  

You don’t see too many metal roofs in urban and suburban areas. However, these roofing systems are quite common in agricultural settings. Metal roofs are available in a variety of styles and colors to match the rest of the house, but they still don’t stand out aesthetically as shingles do.


Generally, asphalt shingles are easier to install than metal roofs. However, if you’re replacing a roof, you may need to remove the previous ones first due to the considerable weight of asphalt shingles. In most cases, insurance and warranty requirements demand that the homeowner removes the previous asphalt shingles.   

As you can expect, removing old shingles adds to the installation time. However, the best contractors in Upstate can significantly reduce the amount of time you need to remove the shingles to a day or two, depending on the size of your home. 

Metal roofing is much lighter than asphalt shingles and can be installed over the previous roof. Of course, the weight will vary depending on what material you decide to use. Aluminum, for instance, is up to five times lighter than steel.

If metal roofing is a lot lighter than asphalt shingles, why do we say that asphalt installation is easier? That’s because when you’re installing a metal roof, there’s the extra step of laying oriented strand board or plywood under the metal. This step is meant to eliminate noise during rain or hail, but it adds extra time and labor into the entire installation process.


The roof vs shingles cost discussion is an easy one to settle. While different kinds of metal roofs will cost differently, with steel and aluminum roofs being the most affordable and copper and zinc being the most expensive, metal roofs are still more expensive than shingle roofing. 

Homeowners who use metal roofing can expect to pay up to three times the cost of using asphalt shingles. It’s one of the top reasons that asphalt is almost always the top choice for contract builders and first-time home buyers.

Energy Efficiency

With a metal roof, you can expect to lower energy bills considerably during the summer. That’s because the reflective surface of metal lowers heat transfer into your home. Conversely, asphalt shingles absorb and transfer heat into your home, forcing your cooling system to work extra hard.

Come winter, the performance of asphalt shingles improves. The heat that your shingles absorbed during the winter keeps your home warmer. But metal roofs also perform well during the winter.

Overall, the energy usage is lower all year-round when you have a metal roof over your head. 

That said, some asphalt shingle roofs carry the Energy Star rating for better energy efficiency. Go for these shingles if you prefer asphalt roofing over other alternatives. 


Metal roofs last remarkably long, off-setting the higher initial cost of installation. Even with little maintenance, a metal roof can last for over 60 years. Many metal roof manufacturers give a 50-year warranty on their product. 

Shingle roofs last much less. During the 60-year period that a metal roof lasts, you’ll need to replace an asphalt shingle roof at least twice. Most manufacturers offer warranties of 20 -25 years for shingle roofs.

In particular, asphalt shingles are prone to storm and hail damage, unless you’re using top-quality varieties such as Atlas designer shingles. Asphalt shingles that do not receive enough adequate sunlight can also accumulate algae, mold, or mildew and deteriorate quickly. 

In contrast, metal roofing systems perform better in bad weather and are impervious to mildew, mold, and bugs.  In many states, homeowners who install fire- and impact-resistant metal roofs are eligible for attractive insurance discounts.

Resale Value

Given that metal roofs are strong, energy-efficient, and durable, they tend to increase a home’s resale value by a higher percentage than asphalt shingle roofs. If you’re investing in a new roof with the intention of selling your home at some point, then it makes more sense to choose metal.

Metal Roof Vs Shingles: The Choice Comes Down to You

Now that you’ve seen how metal roof vs shingles compare, it’s easier to make a decision on what roofing system makes more sense for your needs. If you’re more drawn to affordability, appearance, and ease of installation, then asphalt shingles may be the best option. On the other hand, if it’s variety, energy efficiency, longevity, and resale value you’re after, a metal roof is the better option.

Are you interested in reliable roofing solutions? Please contact us today.